Scrapping HSR a Wise Move, Says Experts

Pavither 1 Jun 2018

The new government’s final decision to axe the Kuala Lumpur-Singapore High Speed Rail (HSR) appears to be a smart move as the project’s high cost is likely to exceed its potential benefits, reported the Sun Daily.

“This project can take longer than envisaged to break even given the stiff competition with other modes of connectivity such as road and air. Much will depend on ticket pricing and ridership,” said AmResearch on Wednesday (30 May).

While there will be some negative consequence for terminating the HSR, the research house believes the negative effects are not tremendous.

For instance, the penalty of up to RM500 million to cancel the project is only about 0.45 percent of its RM110 billion total cost, which appears manageable.

“The move has given some breathing space on savings, especially with the high public debt at RM1.09 trillion or 80.3 percent of the gross domestic product (GDP),” it noted.

However, the axing of the HSR and the MRT3 project or Circle Line have significantly affected the share prices of Malaysia-listed construction companies, resulting in a collective decline of 10.87 percent or 24.42 points.

For instance, Gamuda’s stock price slumped 23 percent to RM3.18, that for Malaysian Resources Corp Bhd (MRCB) fell 16.8 percent to 57 sen, while YTL Corp’s slid 8.8 percent to 93 sen.

Earlier this month, a consortium consisting of Gamuda and MRCB have been appointed to build the civil infrastructure works of the HSR’s northern domestic portion, while a joint venture between YTL and THP bagged the southern segment.

AmResearch said the outlook of the local construction industry appears lacklustre as the new government reviews large-scale projects to trim down debt.

“Apart from the KL-Singapore HSR, we believe more mega projects could potentially be deferred, scaled down or cancelled.”

Furthermore, it said, the implementation of a more transparent public bidding system is expected to lower the profit margins of construction firms.

“Not helping either, are the prolonged downturn in the local property market that weighs on Gamuda’s property division, coupled with the uncertainty arising from the potential expropriation of Gamuda’s toll road and water concessions,” added the research house.

This article was edited by the editorial team of PropertyGuru. To contact them about this or other stories email

For the latest property news, trends, resources and expert opinions, visit our Property News section. Home buyers, sellers or property renters looking for Malaysian Properties, may like to visit the New Launches or Project Reviews page.


You may also like these articles

MRT3 the Most Expensive Public Transportation Ever to be Constructed (Maybe)

CIMB Equities Research described the government’s plan to expedite the construction of the Mass Rapid Transit 3 (MRT3) Circle Line in the Klang Valley as a positive surprise.This comes as they had e

Continue Reading12 Sep 2017

Malaysia Reveals Main HSR Contractors

  MyHSR Corporation announced the names of the two project delivery partners (PDPs) for the Malaysian portion of the Singapore-Kuala Lumpur High Speed Rail (HSR), reported The Star. For the r

Continue Reading4 May 2018

HSR, ECRL Among Major Projects to be Reviewed

  Minister of Economic Affairs Datuk Seri Mohamed Azmin Ali revealed on Tuesday (22 May) that the new Pakatan Harapan government will scrutinise the prior administration’s large-scale projects, rep

Continue Reading24 May 2018

Malaysia Property Market Can Flourish Without HSR

  Experts believe the axing of the Kuala Lumpur-Singapore High Speed Rail (HSR) is likely to have a marginal effect on Malaysia’s real estate market, reported The Edge. “I think some of t

Continue Reading30 May 2018